Welcome!

Featured

Thanks for visiting the Procom CUPE information hub. The aim of this site is to provide information useful for our teaching and professional development and to foster collaboration and mutual support.

The pull-down menu items are static pages providing links to various sites relevant to our teaching and research.  I hope you’ll expand and enrich these preliminary offerings with your own. The posts will be reserved for news items, teaching tips, announcements and recommendations on such topics as contract opportunities, interesting or controversial articles or recent personal achievements. The titles of the posts are captured on the upper right side of the home page. Categories facilitate cross-referencing.

If you have information to post, an idea for a menu item or suggestions for improvement, please email me at lschofie@ryerson.ca.

Job Opportunities: Courses at McMaster

Take a look at the Careers page for the department of Communication Studies and Media Arts at McMaster University for the available courses below:

CMST 2TM6 – Foundations in Communication Theory & Methods
CMST 3II3/POLSCI 3IP3 – Intellectual Property
CMST 3WR3 – Professional Writing
CMST 4D03 – International Communication
CMST 4E03 – Media and Promotionalism
CMST 4N03 – News Analysis: Theory and Practice
MEDIAART 1A03 – Media Arts
MEDIAART 2A06 – Design & Code
MEDIAART 3BB3 – New Media Art Practices
MEDIAART 3K03 – Game Studies

Note that the deadline for applications is June 16.

Job Opportunity: Tenure-Track

The Digital and Communication Studies Department of Ontario Tech University is inviting applications for a tenure-track position for July, 2023. The deadline for receipt of all applications is April 7, 2023.

This opportunity has an indirect ProCom connection. One of our tenured professors, Dr. Isabel Pedersen, joined the faculty at Ontario Tech a number of years ago, where she has continued her research into wearable tech. You can find her profile page here for information on recent publications and awards. She’s now the director of the Decimal Lab and the Digital Life Institute. If you check out her Twitter account, you’ll note she is fully engaged with the debate about AI language systems.

Contemplating ChatGPT

Image by WikiImages from Pixabay

A chart is making the rounds purporting to represent looming advances of Large Language Learning in ChatGPT, showing where we are now (version 3) vs. where we will be soon (version 4) in the automated generation of human-like communication. The thought of ChatGPT 3 alarmed and overwhelmed me enough when I learned students could use the tool to create plausible written documents that I asked both TMU’s AIO and Turnitin.com about ways to safeguard academic integrity. What I learned was not reassuring. This post records what I’ve discovered so far. Undoubtedly a number of you have much more to say on this subject.

My impression of Turnitin.com’s response to AI-created writing is that they’re nowhere near integrating academic-integrity safeguards that we can rely on. TMU’s Office of Academic Integrity currently (February, 2023) admits that it’s not yet possible to detect AI content, nor has Policy 60 been updated to address this issue.

We did have enough notice in September to add a note in our syllabi; however without a reliable tool to combat this kind of plagiarism, we really can’t do much, save having private, probing conversations with students–not a pleasant option. A professor at Innis College’s Writing & Rhetoric program at U of T has told me she may start assigning in-class essays. We could always return to the hand-written in-class writing assignments of yesteryear, but major grumbling, not to mention the headache of marking cursive, are not attractive prospects.

TMU’s Office of Academic Integrity has created a community of practice and provided regular workshops for instructors grappling with this issue. You could ask to be included in the community of practice, and you’ll get a D2L organization on your Brightspace page, where you can see what other members are thinking and can find leads on ways to manage the challenges. Allyson Miller (allyson.miller@torontomu.ca) appears to be the AI point person for the AIO. Topics for the latest workshop’s roundtable discussions reflect the most pressing ones that have emerged at other universities: “how to design assessments that either 1) thwart student use of AI, 2) leverage AI, or 3) challenge and/or critique AI.”

To be honest, I was surprised at how quickly surrender was promoted. Back in December 2022, an article in The Chronicle of Higher Education took this view. Our own AIO office recommended a tip sheet for integrating ChatGPT into the classroom, despite its incoherence and indirect invitation to be a commodity audience. Further afield, Manchester Met has sponsored an open slideshare inviting academics to post their ideas, and so far contributors are more excited than fearful. A common refrain is that we surrender to the ghost in the machine and try to learn from its bloodless shuffling of coherent-sounding sentences.

It’s understandable and probably realistic to contemplate how we’ll adapt, given the inevitable expansion of this tool’s capabilities. Nonetheless, possibly because of my early training and temperament, I prefer to begin with resistance and questions like those produced by Stanford University’s Institute for Human-Centred AI. Though as CUPE lecturers we’re mostly teaching “practical” writing skills, I’d argue we’re also instilling agency and allowing individual students to discover what they’re capable of as communicators. Do we really want to farm out the responsibility for a very human exchange to a non-human voice? I fear that in our effort to discover a solution to simple challenges we’re reaching for the stars but finding the green light on our computer monitors or the mirror image of a blinking cursor from a faceless stranger’s blank page.

Job Opportunity: Sessional Positions

The Department of Communication Studies & Media Arts at McMaster University has two courses advertised for sessional lecturers for the Winter 2023 semester: International Communication (CMST 4D03) and Social Activism in the Media (CMST4P03). This link takes you to the main job ads page, and you then type in the course name to see the description and the instructions for applying. You need to act fast. The deadline for applications is October 26.